Congrats! Now that you’ve made the announcement about your bun in the oven, you’ve also decided to find out your baby’s gender and share the exciting news in a big way. From releasing pink or blue balloons via a gender reveal balloon box to using gender reveal scratch-off cards at a gender reveal party, expectant parents can go to extremes when ensuring the moment of revelation is a memorable one. But no matter how you choose to share the surprise, here are a few key supplies — including invitations, decorations, games and even popcorn — you’ll need to make your gender reveal party a success. Best of all, many of them are readily available from Etsy, Walmart and Target. Check out our favorite finds below!

Funny Gender Reveal Invitations

Best Funny Gender Reveal Party Invitations: Let’s talk about all the good things about this invitation. Do your guests have a naughty or cheeky sense of humor? If so, these funny invitations are best for your gender reveal party. This digital invite is made to order but, sadly, does not guarantee a special guest appearance by Salt-N-Pepa. ($11.50; Shop Now!)

Harry Potter Gender Reveal Invitations

Best Gender Reveal Party Invitations for Potterheads: For all the expectant Muggle parents, this digital download Harry Potter gender reveal party invitation is pure magic. Your guests will hop on the Hogwarts Express (or on their broomsticks!) to attend this party faster than Harry can catch the snitch. What will your baby be, a witch or a wizard? Maybe the Sorting Hat knows. ($12; Shop Now!)

Gender Reveal Party Invitations

Best Classic Gender Reveal Party Invitations: If Harry Potter isn’t your cup of butterbeer — er — tea, we like these simple “He or She” gender reveal party invitations. The classic blue and pink balloon digital invitations are made to order. ($15; Shop Now!)

Cake Topper for Gender Reveal

Best Gender Reveal Party Cake Topper: Forget the icing on the cake — this is the topping that matters. Some parents elect to find out the gender of their baby by cutting into a custom-made cake that reveals the appropriate color filling. But before your guests even dig into the pastry that protects the big secret, they’ll ooh and ahh at the sweet glittery cake topper that pays homage to the most famous lullaby in the world. ($12; Shop Now!)

Welcome Sign for Gender Reveal

Best Gender Reveal Party Welcome Sign: It’s the question on everyone’s minds — and on your lawn! As your eager and curious guests arrive to your gender reveal party, they’ll be greeted by the handmade, weather-resistant sign that stands at a proud 23 inches tall. ($30; Shop Now!)

Ice Cream Gender Reveal Plates

Best Gender Reveal Party Plates: I scream, you scream, we all scream, “Is it a boy or a girl?” Before your guests get the scoop on your baby’s gender, they can lick their ice cream plates clean. These cool paper plates can also be included in the seller’s party pack, which includes cups, napkins, dessert and dinner plates. ($10 – $27; Shop Now!)

Gender Reveal Honey Bee Napkins

Best Gender Reveal Party Napkins: Oh, honey! Could these invitations be any sweeter? The buzz at the party won’t be what the gender of the bay-bee is anymore once your colony of guests set their eyes (and wipe their hands) on these. Each order contains 16 handmade gender reveal napkins. ($4; Shop Now!)

Onesie Gender Reveal Cups

Best Gender Reveal Party Cups: Your very own sippy cup! Guests will imbibe cocktails — or mocktails — from these unique onesie cups. These handmade plastic or vinyl cups are made to order and each order contains 24 cups. Also, there is an assortment of colors to choose from if you don’t want to stick to traditional pink and blue. ($9 – $12; Shop Now!)

Hockey and Lipstick Gender Reveal Buttons

Best Pink and Blue Gender Reveal Party Buttons: Though your little one won’t be wearing lipstick or shuffling a hockey stick just yet, it’s fun to have guests at your gender reveal party sport these unique buttons. Have the partygoers choose one or the other and proudly display their vote. Sets range from 20 to 50 buttons. ($10 – $38; Shop Now!)

Baseball Gender Reveal Buttons

Best Gender Reveal Party Buttons for Sports Fans: As host of this very important party, you want to make sure you have all your bases covered. Decor? Check. Favors? Check. Accessories? Right here! If you’re a sports family, then these gender reveal party supplies are a homerun. Each order contains 100 buttons, but if you prefer, this seller also makes baseball gender reveal magnets. ($25 – $75; Shop Now!)

Gender Reveal Party Favor Labels

Best Gender Reveal Party Custom Labels: Stick these custom-made labels on any gender reveal party favor so your guests can remember the big day. Our favorite use of this label is to place it on mini hand sanitizers and distribute them as party favors! Your guests might see this as an altruistic act, but really, you just want them to save the sanitizer and use it for when they visit your newborn! These labels are printed and mailed directly to you and can also be custom-made in other sizes. ($13.50; Shop Now!)

He or She Gender Reveal Balloons

Best Gender Reveal Party Balloons: You can’t throw a gender reveal party — or any party, for that matter — and not have balloons. A He or a She, what will it be? Doesn’t matter, because you’ll be floating on air either way! The balloons come in sets of 5 and10. ($3.50 – $6; Shop Now!)

Gender Reveal Banner

Best Gender Reveal Party Banner Decoration: Dress up your venue with this clever gender reveal party decoration banner that would look perfect over a dessert table. Will your baby be a little lady or a mini mister? Your guests will soon find out! ($13; Shop Now!)

Gender Reveal Popcorn

Best Gender Reveal Party Snack: Pink or blue? Doesn’t matter when your guests pop this colorful popcorn into their mouths. Each order contains a 3 gallon bag of popcorn. ($38; Shop Now!)

Old Wives Tale Gender Reveal Game

Best Gender Reveal Party Game: Before the big reveal, pass the time playing fun games that your guests will enjoy. This one takes on all the old wives’ tales about pregnancy and gender. Is mom suffering from morning sickness? What type of cravings does she have, salty or sweet? Download it, cast your votes and wait for the winner! ($8; Shop Now!)

Confetti Cannon Shooter Gender Reveal Party

Best Gender Reveal Party Confetti: This confetti cannon shooter might work best if you already know the gender of your baby and want to surprise your guests. The cannon shooter comes with either blue or pink confetti, but is hidden in a gender neutral gold packaging to keep your guests in suspense. ($6; Shop Now!)